19.06.2008  
     
 
Giuliani Levels, Then Draws, National Security Fire For McCain
 
  Rudy Giuliani stepped back into presidential politics Wednesday to boost John McCain's national security-based attacks on Barack Obama, but got an earful from the media, Democrats and bloggers when he made negative remarks about Obama's views that were similar his own views at one time -- and about stances that put him at odds with McCain.

What's fair is fair. If, when Hillary Clinton sticks up for Obama, the Republicans jump all over both of them, they should expect the same back. The most compelling material dredged up on Giuliani is that he criticized Obama for his laudatory remarks about the 1993 World Trade Center case, but Giuliani himself had praised the same convictions for the same reasons back in 1994.

Then, of course, there's the matter of previous Republican primary sniping between McCain and Giuliani. McCain criticized Giuliani for having negligible national security experience -- the very attack he's leveled at Obama. And Giuliani and McCain likewise fought over the legality of interrogation techniques back then, a noteworthy point because it mixes up the message Giuliani was trying to send on behalf of McCain Wednesday about legal issues in the "war on terror."

As I wrote about with Clinton vs. Obama, the issue of Guiliani vs. himself and Giuliani vs. McCain probably won't get the same attention upon subsequent Giuliani forays back into a political campaign, since memories fade. But Wednesday? They were still pretty fresh.
 
 
 
Tim Starks 19.06.2008, 03:20 # 3 Comments
0 Trackbacks
 
 
     
3 Comments

  It really doesn't make sense for Giuliani to be sticking his foot in the door at this point. McCain needs the support of right-wing GOP politicians, not pseudo-Republicans who are more liberal than he is (which is saying something).

That said, what both the previous posters said rings true. Giuliani's comments DID make sense in the pre-9/11 world, but today they are completely out of step, as Obama is.
 
  The Rumbling Conservative | Homepage | 22.06.2008, 14:00  
 
 
  Useless chit chat. US Democrat Party was infected by MARXISM with Democrat President for Life FDR's New Deal. Marxist takeover of the US Democrat Party was completed with the Administration of Democrat Jimmy Carter. Now, Democrat Party is Marxist in policy & leadership which means that it is anti American as well as the JudeoChristian Tradition which created CIVILIZATION. Marxists are as great a threat as Muslim Terrorists which Obama brings TOGETHER.  
  Max Rugemer | Homepage | E-Mail | 20.06.2008, 11:28  
 
 
  The comments Rudy made about the 1993 World Trade Center case make sense in 1994. They don't make sense in a post-September 11 World. Which is why Rudy could criticize Obama about those same comments. The world has changed.  
  Smarter Than You | Homepage | E-Mail | 19.06.2008, 18:32  
 
 
Name
E-Mail
Home
Entry
Home DW-WORLD